FA Defends FA Cup Replay Removal Amid Controversy and Criticism

The Football Association (FA) has defended its decision to eliminate FA Cup replays starting from the 2024-25 season, citing consensus among all involved parties. While the EFL contends that the change was solely agreed upon by the Premier League and the FA, the FA asserts that discussions regarding replay removal have been ongoing for over a year. They emphasize the aim of strengthening competitions while ensuring player welfare amid a constrained schedule.

Despite criticism from various clubs, the FA points out that the decision was approved by the Professional Game Board including representatives from the EFL and the Premier League. Additionally, they highlight plans to increase the number of early-round FA Cup matches broadcasted providing additional revenue opportunities for EFL and National League teams. However, the EFL challenges this assertion, claiming they were effectively advised to accept the decision.

Various figures within football have expressed disappointment with the change, citing its impact on tradition and lower-division clubs. Managers such as Mark Robins, Erik ten Hag, Mikel Arteta and Pep Guardiola have voiced their concerns about player welfare and the preservation of football culture amidst the decision.